If you toss the electoral college, should Senate go too?


Steve Erickson’s article published in the Dec. 3 edition of the South Whidbey Record argues for the elimination of the Electoral College. Part of his rationale is that a democratic election should be based on the premise of each vote being worth the same. He quotes that the Electoral College makes each Washington voter equal to three-eighths of a Wyoming voter. He also traces the Electoral College being established to protect the South’s slave-based economy.

First of all, we are a republic, not a democracy. Each vote in each state carried the same weight.

The Electoral College was also established to protect small states from being outvoted by states with large populations. Two solutions were implemented to protect the small states. One was the Electoral College. Without the Electoral College, about eight states (the coastal, upper mid-west, Texas among them) have enough population to out-vote the rest of the country.

The Senate was the other. Each state has two senators, regardless of population.

If the Electoral College were discarded due to voter inequality, shouldn’t the Senate be eliminated for the same reason?



More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: America does not come first for president

Editor, For Trump to stand next to Putin and think Putin’s suggestion… Continue reading

Letter: Proposed sewage system a bad idea

Editor, I read the article that appeared in the South Whidbey Record… Continue reading

Letter: Trump’s remarks were treasonous

Editor, I was completely stunned and horrified by Donald Trump’s remarks after… Continue reading

Letter: Prepare for the smokescreen on Initiative 1631, fossil fuels

Editor, Initiative 1631 places a fee on sources of carbon dioxide (fossil… Continue reading

Letter: Tom Seguine a good candidate for Washington Appeals Court

Editor, I recently met Tom Seguine and had an in-depth conversation with… Continue reading

Letter: It is worth taking time to read the U.S. Constitution, articles

Editor, It’s getting hard to ignore our national news and the extensively… Continue reading

Letter: Sheriff candidate’s campaign signs violate flag etiquette

Editor, I am disgusted every time I drive past a Lane Campbell… Continue reading

Letter: The Coupeville School board needs greater transparency

Editor, Coupeville School District has an opportunity to set a new standard… Continue reading

The South Whidbey Yacht Club has a wide range of offerings

Editor, First of all, many thanks to reporter Patricia Guthrie for her… Continue reading

Most Read