Letter: Navy would allow toxins to remain in drinking water

Editor,

The Navy and Coupeville’s “path forward” to the solution of the town’s PFAS-contaminated water supply is a slow one that won’t get people the clean water they expect. The promised PFAS filter system is supposed to be finished in late 2019, three years after contamination was discovered.

The Navy admits that PFASs will be reduced, but not eliminated. How much of which PFASs people will still be drinking is the question neither party to the memorandum of understanding will answer.

State-of-the-art filtration systems can drop PFASs levels to single digit parts per trillion. However, the town and Navy’s agreement doesn’t call for one, or for removal of PFASs to the greatest extent possible. Neither does it call for post-filter monitoring and reporting that will reveal the amounts of all PFASs that will remain. At least seven have been found in Coupeville’s water.

The agreement says nothing about the PFHXS and PFHPA in the water. It only calls for reducing PFOA/PFOS to an amount below 70 parts per trillion. This leaves wiggle room for PFASs to remain at levels above the Agency For Toxic Substances And Disease Registry’s proposed Minimum Risk Levels.

The filter is supposed to have “adaptive alternatives” to address “future applicable federal or state drinking water regulations.”

This wording allows PFASs to remain that are not regulated or likely to be regulated in the near future.

The Navy and Coupeville have a history of using detection limits that allowed for some PFASs to go undetected and unreported. Neither will identify the detection limits to be used in the post-filter sampling. This benefits people most concerned about public image and tourist dollars, not those who want to know what’s in their drinking water.

For reasons not yet explained, the decision was made against relocating the town’s main supply well to an uncontaminated area. Doing so might have cost the Navy more money, but it would have assured PFAS-free drinking water.

The terms of the agreement will expire in 10 years, or “whenever the Navy determines the response action is no longer needed.” This kind of wording can leave people drinking PFAS contaminated water and stick taxpayers with costs the Navy should pay. The MOU can and should be altered by mutual agreement

Rick Abraham

Greenbank

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Writer shouldn’t get pulpit for sermon in newspaper

Editor, I have read the letter to the editor by Lorinda Newton… Continue reading

Letter: Fire board experience important in running district

Editor, As candidate for South Whidbey Fire/EMS Board of Commissioners, I offer… Continue reading

Letter: Thank you from the South Whidbey Hearts Hammers

Editor, South Whidbey Hearts & Hammers would like to extend its heartfelt… Continue reading

Letter: People should model good behavior for the children

Editor, In reading the article in the South Whidbey Record and also… Continue reading

Letter: Easter is a time for more than just bunnies, eggs

Editor, Each spring, at parks such as Dan Porter Park or on… Continue reading

Letter: Our Southern resident orcas are in peril

Editor, Living on Whidbey Island is magical, with sweeping views out onto… Continue reading

Letter: Opioid crisis restrictions don’t consider everyone

Editor, Regarding the April 6, 2019 South Whidbey Record article on the… Continue reading

Letter: Why is President Trump afraid to give tax returns?

Editor, So even though President Trump promised to release his tax returns… Continue reading

Letter: Island’s litter crews do a great job, keep us clean

Editor, I wanted to send a shout out to the litter crews… Continue reading

Letter: WhidbeyHealth CEO salary needs to match Whidbey

Editor, As the WhidbeyHealth commissioners consider whether to give the retiring CEO… Continue reading

Letter: WICA play is worth the watch, good for laughs

Editor, Go see the new play at WICA, “Next to Normal.” While… Continue reading

Letter: Please don’t be late with property taxes this year

Editor, Taxpayers of Island County, please take note. Property taxes are due… Continue reading