Letter: Patriot Prayer can’t decide law is unconstitutional

Editor,

First, a quote: “Like most rights, the Second Amendment right is not unlimited … It is not a right to keep and carry any weapon whatsoever in any manner whatsoever and for whatever purpose.”

If we were to use this as a yardstick to determine if Initiative 1639, the gun control measure passed by voters last year, is constitutional, then I’d have to conclude yes. There is nothing in I-1639 that stops me from buying a gun. It will require — among other things — a background check and waiting period. But none of these add up to denying me the right to own a gun.

On Saturday, Feb 1, the group Patriot Prayer held a gathering here on Whidbey Island called “Enforce the Second Amendment: Island County.” It was specifically directed toward I-1639, which they believe is unconstitutional.

Of course, Patriot Prayer is free to believe whatever they wish about the Constitution and I-1639. And the same is true for all of us. What they can not do is presume to speak for me or the majority of voters in this state, and they cannot decide for the rest of us which laws are constitutional and which are not, despite how they feel about them.

That is decided by our courts.

One way they’ve been furthering their position is by asking local elected officials in our state to adopt an ordinance or oath that says they will not enforce “any unconstitutional laws, particularly I-1639.”

There are two issues I have with this. First, all people elected in our state already take an oath where they swear to support the constitutions of our country and our state, and all local ordinances. So, what Patriot Prayer is asking for is redundant and is not needed.

The second reason gets to the real heart of matter: Patriot Prayer is not just asking for elected officials to support the Constitution, but to support Patriot Prayer’s interpretation of it.

And if elected officials buy into this it means they are going beyond their jobs of enforcing the law, and are instead assigning themselves the role of interpreting the law, and then deciding what parts of it they agree or don’t agree with.

This is going far beyond their elected roles and duties, and is in fact neither supporting our constitution, nor supporting our democracy.

Getting back to the quote above. Whom did it come from? Was it Obama, Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders, or any number of other extremists, anarchist, leftist, chicken littles, or knee-jerkers? No.

The quote is from the late, conservative Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, whom I think was far more familiar with the Constitution than I am. And I strongly suspect he knew more about it than Patriot Prayer does as well.

David Freed,

Clinton

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Fear Navy wasn’t working in good faith now confirmed

Editor, I read in the Feb. 2 South Whidbey Record on Feb.… Continue reading

Letter: Something must be done now about global warming

Editor, Climate change is happening now. The latest climate report from the… Continue reading

Letter: Parks and Rec has work to do before asking for money

Editor, Your two front page articles in the Jan. 30 edition of… Continue reading

Letter: Exposure to jet noise is harmful to your health

Editor, Noise exposure from military jets has long been shown to cause… Continue reading

Letter: Wondering if the Navy has problem with credibility

Editor, The Navy Growler EIS makes dubious assertions, as well as verbal… Continue reading

Letter: Fractional reserve lending a good deal for state residents

Editor, Former state treasurer Duane A. Davidson is opposed to the citizens… Continue reading

Letter: Patriot Prayer can’t decide law is unconstitutional

Editor, First, a quote: “Like most rights, the Second Amendment right is… Continue reading

Letter: Dams came at high cost to tribes dependent on salmon

Editor, “Urgent warning: Elected officials, if breaching does not begin this winter,… Continue reading

Letter: Name is Tokitae — don’t label her a ‘killer whale’

Editor, I was very heartened to read Patricia Guthrie’s article about the… Continue reading

Most Read