Letter: Skepticism of Navy over water issue is justified


I just had to respond to the letter from The Record of May 2 from Dennis Burns, “We should be thankful Navy is cleaning water.” Mr. Burns seems to have absolute faith in the good intentions of the Navy. A faith, I assume by the tone of the letter, that comes from having a long employment history with the Navy. I would strongly suggest that Mr. Burns do some reading about the history of water contamination at American military bases. I will mention just one here. Camp Lejeune. This Marine camp had a problem with water contamination directly because of chemicals dumped by the Marine Corp. There are long lists available of chemicals dumped by the base. It was determined that the water people drank and bathed in was “tainted” between 1950 and 1985 with toxins from 240 to 3400 times levels permitted by safety standards. This water was supplied by wells. Sound familiar?

The fact that you would denigrate the concerns of a fellow citizen over the quality of water that may be poisoned by chemicals used in everyday military life, along with a “dog whistle” comment about “American citizens as well as others living here both legally and illegally” and lumping these concerns into a snarky comment intimating that this concerned citizen is exposing an “elitist entitlement attitude” is beyond the pale. Citizens do indeed need to have trust in the service members who run the military business of America, but the problem is actual history and behavior does not make this blind faith tenable. Transparency and honesty are important. You seem to be OK with whatever the Navy wants to say about cleaning the water they have contaminated. I am not. History bears this skepticism of the military industry out.

Dan Freeman


More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Exposure to jet noise is harmful to your health

Editor, Noise exposure from military jets has long been shown to cause… Continue reading

Letter: Wondering if the Navy has problem with credibility

Editor, The Navy Growler EIS makes dubious assertions, as well as verbal… Continue reading

Letter: Fractional reserve lending a good deal for state residents

Editor, Former state treasurer Duane A. Davidson is opposed to the citizens… Continue reading

Letter: Dams came at high cost to tribes dependent on salmon

Editor, “Urgent warning: Elected officials, if breaching does not begin this winter,… Continue reading

Letter: Patriot Prayer can’t decide law is unconstitutional

Editor, First, a quote: “Like most rights, the Second Amendment right is… Continue reading

Letter: Name is Tokitae — don’t label her a ‘killer whale’

Editor, I was very heartened to read Patricia Guthrie’s article about the… Continue reading

Letter: Freeland Library offers limited magazine choices

Editor, A nice remodel on the Freeland Library, but the magazine section… Continue reading

Letter: Navy philosophy dismisses locals’ Growler concerns

Editor, The Langley resident who dismissed the concerns of people living near… Continue reading

Letter: Residents are suffering from Navy’s ‘sonic abuse’

Editor, Re: three letters in the Wednesday Jan. 30 South Whidbey Record… Continue reading

Letter: Patriot Prayer shouldn’t be welcomed on Whidbey

Editor, Patriot Prayer shouldn’t be welcomed on Whidbey Island. You may be… Continue reading

Letter: Where the Patriot Prayer group goes, hate follows

Editor, Your newspaper published an article on Jan. 29 titled “Gun-rights group… Continue reading

We must disavow Patriot Prayer’s ideas, actions

Editor, It is easy to believe that our island is an isolated… Continue reading