Like house fires, global warming can start in different ways

Editor,

David Powell has offered an argument against a significant human contribution to the global warming that we are observing today. The claim that human activity is a major contributor to global warming is “nonsense and a hoax,” he says, because there were warming periods long before there was any human activity to cause them.

There is, however, a fatal flaw in Mr. Powell’s reasoning. You can see it by means of this little parable. Suppose that a neighbor, a certain Mr. Smith, had a house fire 20 years ago. Fortunately, fire fighters were able to put the fire out before too much damage had been done. They investigated the cause and determined that it was an electrical fire — some old wiring had shorted out and started the blaze. Unfortunately, 10 years later Mr. Smith suffered a second fire in his home. This time it proved to be caused by some solvent-soaked rags that he had stored away in his attached garage.

Notice what happened. There were two fires resulting from two different causes. The fact that the first fire was due to an electrical short proved to have no bearing on the explanation for the second fire. The same logic applies to the argument advanced by Mr. Powell. We have had warming (and cooling) periods in the past, explainable by natural causes. This does not mean that the warming we are experiencing now is due exclusively to those same natural causes.

Climate scientists are keenly aware of past warming periods. After all, they are the ones who have provided the evidence for them. It is a genuine scientific challenge to tease out how much of the climate change we see today is due to human activity and how much would have occurred anyway. The evidence for a major human contribution is very strong, but is certainly open to discussion. The argument that Mr. Powell advances, however, is logically flawed and should be discarded. It only confuses the discussions that really need to take place.

JOHN PALKA

Langley

More in Letters to the Editor

See if Langley joins carbon initiative Dec. 18

Editor, Let’s hear it for the City of Langley for they’ve consented… Continue reading

Need to lobby legislators to keep net neutrality

Editor, Ready to send more money to your Internet service provider (ISP)?… Continue reading

Enjoyed Island Transit’s birthday celebration

Editor, I want to thank Island Transit for sharing its birthday celebration… Continue reading

Americans must show Trump that he’s wrong

Editor, It was Maya Angelou who once told us, “When someone shows… Continue reading

Happy to be back and serving the community

Editor, To our island community and beyond: Thank you! Thank you! Thank… Continue reading

South Whidbey does in fact have a public pool

Editor, I take exception to your claim that South Whidbey has no… Continue reading

Inclusive city decision far from transparent

Editor, Quite opposite to The South Whidbey Record’s front page headline on… Continue reading

Students can learn from recent South Whidbey Record article

Editor, I’m writing in response to the South Whidbey Record article Saturday… Continue reading

Great items to be found at local church bazaars

Editor, Thanks so much to the churches that donate their love and… Continue reading

Don’t eliminate parking spots for wider sidewalks

Editor, Regarding the parking in Langley, I was quite surprised to read… Continue reading

Hold contractors and home services companies accountable

Editor, This is an open letter to the many local contractors and… Continue reading

Gun reform is needed in America

Editor, Anticipating a reaction to The Record’s Nov. 8 editorial advocating a… Continue reading