Participants determine ‘Deadly Deed’ culprit at Langley Mystery Weekend

Langley’s 30th annual mystery weekend came to a close Sunday as residents and out-of-towners cracked the case of “The Deadly Deed.”

Zach McKenna

Langley’s 30th annual mystery weekend came to a close Sunday as residents and out-of-towners cracked the case of “The Deadly Deed.”

More than 1,000 people joined fictional detective I.B. Fuzz to solve the murder during Langley Mystery Weekend, a live murder-mystery produced by the Langley Chamber of Commerce. The complex story, by Loretta Martin, wove together 24 characters as suspects in the murder of fictional Italian citizen Carmelo Geaherdelli.

On the first day, suspicions were scattered amongst the characters as clues were gathered from more than 30 participating businesses.

For Evan Mahnken of Bellevue, the top suspect was one of the 49ers club members. The club claimed ownership of the deceased Geaherdelli’s properties.

Mahnken is no newbie to Langley’s mysteries. This was his sixth year participating in the event with his family.

Mahnken spent some time questioning Geaherdelli’s son, Dino, regarding his whereabouts the night of his father’s murder in front of Good Cheer Thrift Store. The son dodged Mahnken’s questions in front of a growing crowd of passers-by, but revealed to Mahnken he did not know how his father earned his fortune.

The mystery has become a tradition for the family which visits restaurants and the South Whidbey area during the annual mystery weekend.

Kirkland resident Zach McKenna’s primary suspect was character Max Lawless, who represented a real estate developer interested in Geaherdelli’s assets.

“I don’t know why, he just seems creepy,” Zach explained.

Zach, 12, sought clues from the scene of the crime at Langley Library and tried to make sense of the evidence he saw: a feather, pen, folder and blood. 

This was Zach’s third time participating in the event. Zach said he liked how the community came together to solve the mystery. He hoped to solve the crime after being really close last year.

“In fact, I almost got it,” he said.

For his mom, Cerise Vablais, the event was a chance to get together with friends from as far away as Nevada. Together they enjoyed visiting Langley stores as they retrieved clues for the mystery.

Karen Shetler, owner of Mykens Pet Boutique, said having the event and clues located in her store made for a busy two days.

“It’s a great weekend, it’s nice to have this spark during the winter,” she said.

She added being dog-friendly helps people and pets feel more welcome in the store. Over the years Shetler said she recognizes people who come back for the event, but more often recognizes the dogs rather than the owners. The boutique has been part of mystery weekend since 2006, with Shetler even playing characters.

Rachel McDougald, who played the widow, Mrs. Candace Geaherdelli, has been participating in the event for 20 years with her family. Her first year she was pregnant with her son Sean, who also was part of the event as Geaherdelli’s son, Dino.

In her part, McDougald plays a widow who is upset from the commotion of dealing with lawyers surrounding her husband’s death.

One of her favorite parts of the event is the rumors that develop over the weekend.

She said it’s fun to see how the story morphs as the weekend progresses. After people get the clues and have a night to talk over the storyline with others, McDougald said people sometimes come back thinking up “bizarre things and plot twists” that aren’t part of the story.

Last year she remembered a rumor began that suggested her character’s favorite food was Jello and a hint in the mystery. But it wasn’t part of the script and people thought it was a clue, she said.

Overall, McDougald enjoyed interacting with people and giving them clues to the storyline.

“I’m just having fun lying to people,” she said.


More in Life

Mucking about for clams

‘Digging for Dinner’ a popular Sound Water activity

Scorch is a play about gender identification showing at Outcast’s black box theater on the Island County fairgrounds June 13-17. It’s a one-person play, performed by Carmen Berkeley. Director and co-producer Ty Molbak went to middle school in Langley was was active in Whidbey Children’s Theater. Both will be seniors at Rutgers University in the fall. One scene in the play “Scorch” portrays the main character looking into mirrors and wondering what others see.
‘Scorch’ looks at first love and ‘gender fraud’

Irish play revolves around one character’s confusion

Whidbey Island Garden Tour highlights five homes

Tickets still available for Saturday event

Jordan Shelley, 18, stands outside his home in Greenbank. He recently received the Sydney S. McIntyre Jr Scholarship from Skagit Valley College to go toward his tuition at the University of Washington. Shelley will pursue his childhood dream of becoming a doctor. Photo by Laura Guido/Whidbey News Group
SVC grad earns full 2-year scholarship to UW

A lot has changed since Jordan Shelley was 7 years old and… Continue reading

Couple creates Whidbey’s first commercial cidery

Driftwood Hard Cider taps into growing market

‘Slowgirl’ explores the human condition in intimate setting

Even with significant professional credentials, the latest offering from Whidbey’s Outcast Theatre… Continue reading

Homegrown ‘Frijole Friday’

Fundraiser features student crops, cooking

Scott Swenson, a National Park Service carpenter, puts the final pieces in on a ramp on the newly restored Pratt Sheep Barn. The 1930s barn will serve as a classroom one it officially opens in July. Photo by Laura Guido/Whidbey News Group
Historic sheep barn repurposed

Tucked away on the Pratt Loop Trail, a formerly dilapidated 1930s sheep… Continue reading

‘Art with a Message’

Students worldview a kaleidoscope of visions

Hometown Hero: Lewis Pope

Once every year a South Whidbey senior is chosen by the South… Continue reading

Shhh…it’s a surprise party for old-timer Bill Lanning

Friends, customers invited to celebrate former owner of Bill’s Feed Tack

New look for familiar frozen treat

Whidbey Island Ice Cream gets a modern makeover