Whidbey News Group photo Wednesday afternoon, North Whidbey resident John Wallace visits with Buster, a mule that suffered a mysterious eye injury earlier this month.

Animal mutilations terrifying Whidbey Island family

A North Whidbey family is feeling terrorized by a prowler they believe injured livestock on their small farm over the last month.

John Wallace, who lives south of Oak Harbor, said the death of a mule and mysterious injuries to two others led him to put up game cameras, one of which captured an eerie photo of someone with a flashlight in the middle of the property at night.

“It’s devastating. It’s terrorizing,” he said. “We feel like hostages.”

The family’s story, as well as photos, is circulating on social media all over Whidbey Island. Wallace said he’s received more than 30 offers of help from people who saw his posts as he plots ways to catch the perpetrator.

Island County Animal Control Officer Carol Barnes was at the farm this week to speak with Wallace and look at the evidence. She said she couldn’t comment on the ongoing investigation.

The family of five had seven mules, which Wallace described as their “four-legged kids.” The big animals — the offspring of a male donkey and a female horse — are reliable, sure-footed animals that for a strong bond with their humans, Wallace said.

Wallace said trouble started on Jan. 26 when he noticed Buster, the biggest of the mules, had an eye swollen shut. On closer inspection, he found the eye was lacerated from some kind of blunt-force trauma. A week and a half later, a mule named Lotta started limping. He found an perfectly straight “incision” on her right flank while a leg on the other side was swollen.

A veterinarian sutured Buster’s eyeball and Lotta’s flank and both have healed, though Lotta’s leg is still swollen. Wallace said he thought at first the injuries were accidental, though he couldn’t figure out how they could have happened.

Then an older but “very healthy” mule named Tucker mysteriously dropped dead, he said. Wallace wasn’t able to determine the cause of death because there was no trauma and the cost of a necropsy is prohibitive.

Wallace said he found evidence that an intruder had been on the farm, including cut fences and an unplugged fence charger.

A game camera caught an image of an intruder, but the person’s face is obscured because of the glare of a flashlight. Wallace moved the cameras to different areas but only caught images that appear to be flashlights.

Tuesday night, Wallace’s son scared away a stranger from the farm just before 8 p.m., Wallace said.

He’s called 911 three times about the incidents, he said, but he understands that deputies with the Island County Sheriff’s Office are stretched thin and limited in what they can do. The property is surrounded by other farms with livestock that haven’t had any problems, he said.

Wallace said he’s convinced that the animals’ injuries and the trespassing on his property are related. He believes that someone is targeting his farm — or perhaps his mules — for a reason unknown to him. His hope, he said, is to catch the “sick” person he believes has been hurting his oversized pets.

“I’m really just filled with rage,” he said, adding that he hasn’t slept well in days. “Just pure rage.”

Whidbey News Group photo Wednesday afternoon, North Whidbey resident John Wallace visits with Buster, a mule that suffered a mysterious eye injury earlier this month.

More in News

Historical society to lead presentation about Gabelein family history

Pick up a local phone book. Thumb to the page with the… Continue reading

South End getting first drug treatment center

Freeland will soon be home to the first medicaid-funded substance use disorder… Continue reading

Langley man airlifted after rollover crash

A Langley resident was airlifted for treatment after rolling his 1995 Ford… Continue reading

Knox Shannon, 8, looks out the window of his new bedroom in the house built by Habitat for Humanity. Island County is set to implement fee changes that would result in savings for the organization, and other developers, in the plan review stage of receiving building permits. Photo by Patricia Guthrie/ Whidbey News-Times
New building permit fees should reduce costs in county

The Board of Island County Commissioners is set to vote on building… Continue reading

Laura Guido/Whidbey News Group
                                The Kettles trails were acquired by Island County in 1996 using funds from the conservation futures program. The county is now accepting applications for the 2018 award cycle, but a low fund balance may limit the acceptance of new projects.
No guarantees for awarding of conservation futures funds

The Island County Conservation Futures Program is now accepting applications from eligible… Continue reading

No injuries in pair of crashes

Two car crashes on Wednesday in Clinton did not result in any… Continue reading

Firefighter stops chicken coop fire, helps save Langley home

A quick response by a local firefighter may have helped save a… Continue reading

Photo provided
                                A evidence photo taken by police shows a deputy’s AR-15 rifle that was involved in a police-related shooting on North Whidbey in September.
Review: Deputy justified in fatal shooting

A deputy was justified in fatally shooting Navy sailor Nicholas K. Perkins… Continue reading

Planning Commission member Tracy Gilroy speaks during a meeting on Monday. The commission voted to approve amendments made in response to a settlement agreement between Island County and the Whidbey Island Environmental Action Network. Photo by Laura Guido/Whidbey News-Times
Forest practices changes heading to board

Island County Planning Commission voted Monday to amend code related to forest… Continue reading

Most Read