Appeals court hears Nichols case

The state Appeals Court heard arguments over a South Whidbey vehicular homicide case last week.

But a final resolution in the case may still be months away.

Michelle D. Nichols was convicted in a bench trial of vehicular homicide for causing the Feb. 14, 2015, collision that resulted in the death of South Whidbey resident Timothy Keil, but she isn’t serving time while the appeals process continues.

Island County Chief Criminal Prosecutor Eric Ohme said he thought it went well before the appeals court, but he won’t know for sure until the appeals court publishes an opinion.

Ohme said he expects the ruling to come in about six weeks.

If the appeals court agrees with the prosecution, Nichols’ attorneys can appeal to the state Supreme Court. If that happens, Ohme said, the case may not be resolved until early 2019.

If he loses, Ohme said he will retry the case, but in front of a jury.

In a bench trial, a judge rather than a jury hears the evidence and comes to a verdict. Ohme said both sides agreed to a bench trial to avoid having more than one full jury trial and to expedite the process.

The process, however, has taken longer than he thought it would, Ohme conceded.

The defense asked for continuances at the Court of Appeals several times.

The question for the appeals court is whether blood evidence obtained at the hospital from Nichols — nearly four hours after the crash and after blood transfusions — can be used as evidence against her.

Island County Superior Court Judge Vickie Churchill ruled in a pre-trial hearing that state troopers had the requisite probable cause to take her blood and that exigent circumstances were sufficient to allow a warrantless blood draw.

In the bench trial, Churchill found Nichols guilty of the “DUI prong” of the vehicular homicide statute and sentenced her to 126 months in prison, which is the maximum.

A person can be found guilty of vehicular homicide if he or she causes a fatal collision by operating a vehicle in one of three ways: while under the influence of drugs or alcohol, in a reckless manner or with disregard for the safety of others.

As part of the deal between the prosecution and defense, Nichols was allowed to remain free until the appeal is decided. She was ordered to wear an ankle bracelet to ensure she doesn’t drink alcohol, according to Ohme.

Briefs prepared by Ohme and the defense attorney agree on the facts of the case. Just after 8:30 p.m. on Valentine’s Day 2015, Kiel was driving a 1993 Honda Accord on State Highway 525. Nichols was driving a 1988 Ford van in the opposing direction.

The van drifted to the right and struck a guardrail. She then drove the van across the center line and into the opposing lane of traffic, striking Keil’s car head on.

Keil died at the scene.

Nichols was also seriously injured and airlifted to Harborview Medical Center in Seattle. Blood samples were taken at the hospital while she was unconscious and being prepped for surgery. Tests later showed that three hours and 51 minutes after the collision, her blood-alcohol level was 0.11 percent, more than the 0.08 percent state limit.

More in News

Advisory Board holding public hearing on draft short-term rental ordinance

What rules should apply to homeowners who rent out houses, rooms or… Continue reading

Island County seeking District 1 applicants for planning commission

The Island County Board of Commissioners is seeking applicants from District 1,… Continue reading

Whidbey Community Foundation Receives $10K for census work

Whidbey Community Foundation received $10,000 in funding from the Washington Census Equity… Continue reading

WICA announces auditions for 20th season

The 2019-20 season marks Whidbey Island Center for the Arts’ 20th theater… Continue reading

Hands off the baby seals

Advocates for marine mammals are making their annual pitch to beach watchers… Continue reading

Former bank employee sentenced for theft

A former employee at an Oak Harbor bank was sentenced to jail… Continue reading

Commission OKs changes to fall bear-hunting rules

The Washington Fish and Wildlife Commission approved changes to the fall bear-hunting… Continue reading

Earthquake felt on Whidbey Island

People across Whidbey Island were awakened by an earthquake early Friday morning.… Continue reading

Conservation District looks at ‘rates and charges’ system

Whidbey Island Conservation District officials are considering going to a different kind… Continue reading

Most Read