City of Langley wins PRA lawsuit

  • Saturday, July 29, 2017 6:00am
  • News

The city of Langley has prevailed in a lawsuit brought by Clinton resident Eric Hood over alleged breaches of the state’s Public Records Act.

Langley Mayor Tim Callison said the city received a notification on July 11 that it was successful in a motion for summary judgment and dismissal of Hood’s lawsuit. Hood claimed the city violated the state’s Public Records Act (PRA) “by failing to produce personal journals from its former mayor that had been destroyed prior to his request, failing to provide him access to records without making a claim of exemption and not providing the plaintiff with emails directly relating to him “pursuant to his modified request,” according to court documents.

Island County Superior Court Judge Vicki Churchill issues the judgment.

On Jan. 5 2016, Hood sought any records kept or created by Fred McCarthy, the former mayor of Langley, and specifically records “that are or were maintained” in a locked cabinet in McCarthy’s office as well as “pocket notebooks” used by McCarthy. Another party had asked for McCarthy’s notebooks prior to Hood’s request, and after receiving advice from the city attorney that his personal notebooks were not considered public records but “personal in nature,” McCarthy destroyed them. The court found McCarthy’s notebooks were not public records under RCW 42.56.010(3).

Because the records did not exist when Hood made his request, the city could not provide the personal journals to Hood, according to the ruling. Hood claimed there were “genuinely disputed material facts” as to whether the records were destroyed and cited inconsistencies in the “sent” time signatures of emails in declarations provided by McCarthy and City Clerk Debbie Mahler.

The court ruled that time inconsistencies are “not material,” and that the undisputed fact is that McCarthy destroyed his personal journals no later than Dec. 17, 2015 and “long before” Hood’s public records request on Jan. 5, 2016.

Hood also argued that the city negligently provided him access to private records of third parties, but there is no cause of action in the Public Records Act if a public agency acted in good faith in attempting to comply with the request, the ruling said.

Finally, the court found the city was “not perfect” but “adequate” in its search for electronic files referencing Hood’s name or his dealings with the city. The ruling also said Hood was not entitled to sift through McCarthy’s city laptop per his request to search for the documents himself because he did not identify the document in question “with sufficient clarity.”

Hood maintains the evidence shows the city of Langley “carefully concealed public records while carelessly disclosing private information about dozens of persons, including police officers, minors, and city job applicants.

“Since the court relied almost exclusively upon the self serving and contradictory declarations of city officials, including former Mayor McCarthy, I have formally asked the court to reconsider its ruling,” Hood wrote in an email Friday afternoon.

More in News

Roll the dice for charity at bunco event

Guild 21 of Providence General Children’s Association is hosting its 14th annual… Continue reading

Community weaves together fundraiser after fiber theft

In late February, Lydia Christiansen and her husband Alan woke up to… Continue reading

Navy extends comment period on special ops training

The area where the Navy conducts special operations training may be expanded… Continue reading

State Parks offer two free pass days in April

The Washington State Parks and Recreation Commission invites the public to celebrate… Continue reading

Photo by Drew Kampion
                                Buell Neidlinger played the cello on Whidbey Island in recent years, but he was famous for his bass playing. He passed away March 16.
Neidlinger remembered as world-class musician

With a long beard and strong opinions, Buell Neidlinger was a well-known… Continue reading

Students speak out on school violence

‘They are leading by example’

Backlog of repairs needed at WhidbeyHealth

Officials explain need for $20 million federal loan

New shuttle for whale watchers

Van replaces chug-chugging cart

School violence topic of public forum

Students to lead discussion at WICA talk

Most Read