Evan Thompson / The Record — The Langley City Council voted 3-0 to adopt an inclusive city ordinance on Monday night at city hall. Councilman Bruce Allen, second from the left, was instrumental in bringing it back after it was shelved in June, despite opposing it earlier this year.

Evan Thompson / The Record — The Langley City Council voted 3-0 to adopt an inclusive city ordinance on Monday night at city hall. Councilman Bruce Allen, second from the left, was instrumental in bringing it back after it was shelved in June, despite opposing it earlier this year.

In surprise 3-0 vote, Langley becomes a inclusive city | UPDATED

Langley is officially an inclusive city by ordinance.

In a surprising turn of events, a Langley City councilman, who for months staunchly opposed the immigration-related ordinance, became its champion during Monday’s regular monthly meeting.

Bruce Allen was instrumental in bringing the ordinance, which people commonly refer to as a sanctuary city ordinance, back after it was shelved by the council in June. It effectively limits the city’s cooperation with the federal government in enforcing federal immigration laws and prohibits targeting people based solely on religious, ethnic, civil or immigration status. Section 9.01.010 of the ordinance further states that “the enforcement of civil and administrative immigration laws is a responsibility of the federal government.”

Allen and council members Dominique Emerson and Thomas Gill voted in favor of it. Council members Ursula Shoudy and Burt Beusch abstained.

Allen’s change of mind came out of the blue. Reading from a prepared statement during the first few minutes of the meeting, he said the council spent a “tremendous amount of time and energy and thoughtful consideration of the matter.”

“As one of the primary objectors to the passage of this ordinance, I wanted to make sure that this action was not taken place as a result of high emotions and the actions of a vocal minority,” Allen said. “Since the time the ordinance was tabled, I have continued to consider the issue and seek additional input from the residents of Langley and have decided that there may be a modest majority who would encourage its passage.

“I would like to add the inclusive city ordinance to the agenda and recommend its passage.”

Allen also wished for the council to end the two-year legislative period with a record of 100 percent agreement. He motioned that the ordinance crafted months earlier be moved past a first reading to a second reading.

It initially drew resistance from Shoudy and Emerson, who each said they felt caught off-guard. Emerson said she was displeased that Allen did not request the ordinance be put on the agenda and involve the public. She also said she did not have adequate time to reexamine the ordinance and evaluate modifications made to it prior to a June 15 council meeting.

Shoudy said she felt a responsibility to uphold the wishes of her constituents who are against the ordinance, even if she has mixed feelings about the discussion.

Gill was also critical of the lack of public involvement — only seven members of the public were in the audience. He requested that a second reading be held until the council’s meeting in December, and that there could be repercussions without due and timely notice.

Both Gill and Emerson voted against the ordinance moving to a second reading; Beusch abstained.

Mayor Tim Callison, who himself previously opposed the ordinance, citing a concern it would violate his oath of office, became the tiebreaker when the motion stalled at a 2-2 vote. Callison opted to move it forward.

Callison said his concern is covered in the ordinance, which was crafted by City Clerk/Treasurer Debbie Mahler and modified by the city’s attorney, Mike Kenyon of Kenyon Disend. Section 9.01.80 of the ordinance makes clear that a violation of the ordinance will not result in any disciplinary or administrative action, nor does it constitute a violation of any oath of office.

“My primary concern had always been whether or not the ordinance would compel staff and elected officials to break their oath of office,” Callison said. “I believe in the last version, Kenyon took care of that very well. I no longer have that concern.”

The ordinance was also modified to allow Langley police officers to continue “fulfilling their duties under LMC (Langley Municipal Code) Chapter 2.18 to investigate and make lawful arrests for violations of city, state, and federal criminal laws.” Police will not be prevented from providing a liaison function to federal agents when requested for “peacekeeping measures,” so long as city funds or resources are not used to “stop, question, interrogate, investigate, or arrest persons based on civil or immigration status.” They will also continue engaging in steps necessary to comply with the Public Records Act, federal laws such as the I-9 Employment Eligibility Verification Process and any action that is required by federal or state statute, local law or a court order.

Callison said it was a preventative measure to avoid a potential lawsuit if a police officer violates the ordinance when conducting his or her duty under Langley Municipal Code.

Members of community advocacy group Inclusive Langley, which spearheaded the public’s effort for an ordinance, took issue with the modifications.

“If there are no consequences for violating the law (in this case an ordinance) then it isn’t really a law, is it?” wrote Natasha Dworkin, a spokesperson for the group, in an email Tuesday afternoon. “I think it will be important for citizens to keep working with the Langley police department to ensure that inclusiveness is more than just a pretty word in Langley.”

Fran Abel, a Langley resident and member of Inclusive Langley, agreed that the ordinance lacks teeth.

“The lawyer put in that no employee or police officer could be held accountable for violating this ordinance,” Abel said. “That makes it useless. If we can’t stop a powerful employee in uniform or not, legally, then we have no power and it means nothing.”

Allen later said he had his reasons for pushing the ordinance forward in bombshell fashion, explaining he feared that the subject would renew a long-debated discussion that spanned from November 2016 to June 2017 and lead to another standstill.

“Because we’d be right back to square one,” he said.

Allen could not be reached for comment after multiple attempts on Tuesday morning and afternoon.

More in News

Glaiza Price, who owns and operates Cosmic Ice Cream with her husband Patrick, peeks out the van’s window. The space-themed van has started popping up at events this year to serve 24 flavors of soft serve ice cream. Photo by Laura Guido/Whidbey News-Times
‘Out of this world’ ice cream rolls onto island

An encounter with an ice cream van in New York, a conversation… Continue reading

County finishing Freeland zone code

Staff from Island County Planning and Community Development will hold a community… Continue reading

Left to right: Eva Wirth, Emma Callahan, Chloe Goethel, Macie Vande Werfhorst, Naomi Atwood, Gabe Gandarias, Maddox Smith-Heacox & Max Rodriguez. Not pictured: Emmett Layman, Zander Kuschnerei and coach Clyde Monma.
SW Middle School Math Teams Capture 5 Medals

South Whidbey Middle School entered five teams in the Washington State Math… Continue reading

WhidbeyHealth nurses trained to assess victims of sexual assault are left to right: Jackie Blankenship, Rebecca Pina, program manager Jackie Bassett, Jacqueline Moore and Sherry Phay. Cynde Robinson, director of Coalition against Domestic Violence, is in the back row. Team member nurses Krista Burckhardt, Gayle Wallen and Tonya DeYoung were unavailable for the photo.
Sexual assault victims can be assessed locally

WhidbeyHealth trains specialty nurse team

Aurora Coffey
South Whidbey High School student wins AAUW prize

South Whidbey High School student, Aurora Coffey, won First Place and a… Continue reading

Town talk pinpoints people and paths

Langley takes step in mapping trails

Langley Police Chief David Marks
Prosecutor declines to charge chief

The Island County prosecutor declined to charge Langley Police Chief David Marks… Continue reading

Island County looks at building air park road

Island County will apply for a grant to study the potential of… Continue reading

Photo provided 
                                Left to right: Grace Callahan, Carli Newman, Oliana Stang, Sean Miles, Magnus Nyberg, Max Rodriguez, Aidan O’Brien, Annika Hustad (Not pictured: Coach Clyde Monma)
SW High School math teams place 1st in state

Three South Whidbey High School math teams earned a trip to the… Continue reading

Most Read