Investigation closed with little evidence of attack

Police closed an investigation into allegations that “Hispanic men” assaulted a teenage girl on South Whidbey June 7 after finding no evidence to back up the alleged victim’s story, which seemed to have inconsistencies, according to police reports.

The girl’s mother reported to the Island County Sheriff’s Office that the girl stopped at a coffee stand on Howard Road on her way to school and saw two men assaulting a dog. The girl got out of her car to intervene, but one of the men pushed her to the ground and started kicking her in the side, according to the police report.

The girl described the men as Hispanic, possible construction workers, who were driving a rusty, red truck.

At school, the girl felt a lot of pain in her side and went to the school nurse, who called her mother and recommended that she be taken to the ER for a possible spleen injury, the report states.

The woman took her daughter to a clinic in Everett, according to the report.

Security video from the car wash did not show the alleged assault, the alleged perpetrators or the red truck. People who had been in the area reported that they hadn’t seen anything.

Video from the coffee stand showed that neither the girl nor the red truck had been there that day, a detective wrote in his report. The girl’s description of the barista did not match anyone who was working that day.

The girl later changed her story and said she fabricated the part about going to the coffee stand, the report states.

In an interview with a deputy, the girl admitted she had participated in a “fight club” but hadn’t done it for a long time, the deputy wrote. She continued to maintain that the men assaulted her, the report states.

The girl’s mother left a small poster describing the alleged assault at a nearby business. It ended up being posted on social media and generated angry comments about the alleged assailants.

More in News

Series of felony cases on Whidbey Island involve impaired driving

Police and prosecutors on Whidbey Island have been busy in recent weeks… Continue reading

Neil Colburn recently closed Neil’s Clover Patch after about 40 years in Bayview. (Photo by Jessie Stensland /South Whidbey Record)
After 36 years, luck changes at Neil’s Clover Patch Cafe

To the surprise of many, the doors were locked, the grill turned… Continue reading

WhidbeyHealth still short on cash

A persistent decline in inpatient visits is contributing to low cash reserves… Continue reading

Extortion plan increases bail for molester suspect

A judge in Island County Superior Court increased a suspected child molester’s… Continue reading

(File photo)
Whidbey Island Fair kicks off Thursday, runs July 18-21

Fair has showcased Whidbey Island agriculture, local talent for over 90 years

Islanders join protest against detention centers

Vigils, signs and demonstrations across Whidbey Friday

Advisory Board holding public hearing on draft short-term rental ordinance

What rules should apply to homeowners who rent out houses, rooms or… Continue reading

Island County seeking District 1 applicants for planning commission

The Island County Board of Commissioners is seeking applicants from District 1,… Continue reading

Whidbey Community Foundation Receives $10K for census work

Whidbey Community Foundation received $10,000 in funding from the Washington Census Equity… Continue reading

Most Read