Island County’s toad protection lacking, state board rules

Island County needs to do a better job of protecting the western toad, a state board recently ruled. The Growth Management Hearings Board again found the county’s comprehensive plan is out of compliance with state rules regarding habitat protection of the western toad, which is a candidate for listing as a state species of concern.

A state board recently found the county's comprehensive plan is out of compliance with state rules regarding habitat protection of the western toad.

Island County needs to do a better job of protecting the western toad, a state board recently ruled.

The Growth Management Hearings Board again found the county’s comprehensive plan is out of compliance with state rules regarding habitat protection of the western toad, which is a candidate for listing as a state species of concern.

It was the second time that the hearings board sided with the environmental group, Whidbey Environmental Action Network, commonly known as WEAN, over the toad issue.

The hearings board ruled in the county’s favor on three other issues that WEAN challenged, finding that the county’s new protections for the “natural area preserve,” rare plants and prairies are adequate.

Island County Commissioner Rick Hannold said the board’s toad decision is just a minor wording issue. He said the county will easily be able to gain compliance by listing the three specific areas where the state has found upland occurrences of the toad, in addition to a wetland breeding site that is already identified; the areas would have special protections from development and other uses that would harm the toads.

“They are challenging that we don’t designate everywhere the toads could possibly occur,” he said, “which I think is ridiculous.”

Erickson, however, said it’s more than a minor issue and designating specific areas won’t fix the problem if there’s not clear and substantial protections in place for those areas.

Under the county’s rules, any proposed development, clearcutting or other earth-disturbing activity within 1,000 feet of a designated area would trigger a biological site assessment, Hannold said. Erickson said it should be at least a kilometer, noting the importance of maintaining habitat connectivity.

“The Hearings Board ruled that the best available science requires protection of all known occurrences of the species, including its upland habitat,” according to a statement from WEAN.

During the hearing before the board, WEAN objected to attorney Susan Drummond being allowed to represent the county. Drummond was hired by the county commissioners to advise and represent the county in matters related to the comprehensive plan, but Island County Prosecutor Greg Banks objected. He argued that commissioners are barred from hiring attorneys to do the job of his office without his consent. He sued and his lawsuit was recently heard before the state Supreme Court.

The hearings board members ruled they don’t have the jurisdiction to rule on the question of who is authorized to represent the county.

WEAN has succeeded in the past four years in pushing the county to create regulations that protect wildlife, according to the group.

“We are now arguing whether it’s enough protection,” said Steve Erickson of WEAN. “Originally the county argued that they didn’t have to provide any protections.”

The Growth Management Act required the county to update its wildlife protection regulations by 2005, but the county failed to do so. The group challenged the county and the hearings board ordered the county to complete the update by September of 2014. WEAN again challenged the county’s compliance and the hearings board ruled against the county on multiple issues last year, according to WEAN.

The county created new regulations and asked the hearings board to be found in compliance. WEAN objected, the hearings board held a hearing in August and issued its decision this month.

Erickson said he doesn’t know yet whether he will appeal.

 

More in News

Washington State House Republican Communications photo — Rep. Norma Smith, R-Clinton, introduced a bill to enforce net neutrality in Washington state.
Rep. Smith, R-Clinton, introduces net neutrality bill

The day before the Federal Communications Commission ended net neutrality, a Republican… Continue reading

Parking proposal makes Langley business owners uneasy

Two design proposals concerning changes to parking on First Street in Langley… Continue reading

Safe Ride Home revs up for second run

A sign with the words “please don’t drink and drive” was erected… Continue reading

Counties pressure state to fund mandates

Island County is joining an effort to get the state’s attention regarding… Continue reading

A house for sale in Coupeville. Island County recently completed a housing needs analysis and found most of the available housing stock are single-family homes, which leaves a deficit for lower income individuals. Photo by Laura Guido/Whidbey News-Times
Report outlines countywide housing needs

A recent housing needs analysis found a significant deficit in available, affordable… Continue reading

New South Whidbey School Board director sworn in

Freeland resident Andrea Downs was sworn into position 2 on the South… Continue reading

Gym floor project at South Whidbey Elementary School South Campus gets new cost

A previous bid for new gym flooring at South Whidbey Elementary School… Continue reading

Police investigating report that Oak Harbor student was accosted

Oak Harbor police are investigating a report that a student was accosted… Continue reading

New tenants added to South Whidbey Community Center

The South Whidbey School Board approved five new leases for tenants at… Continue reading

Most Read