Journalists criticize proposal giving the legislature exemptions to public disclosure laws

  • Wednesday, February 13, 2019 2:52pm
  • News

By Emma Epperly

WNPA Olympia News Bureau

Media organization representatives from across Washington lambasted proposed legislation that exempts the legislature from portions of the Public Records Act.

As the proposed bill moves through the legislative process, a related court case also moves through the judicial process.

The Senate State Government and Tribal Relations and Elections Committee took public testimony Wednesday on Senate Bill 5784 proposed by Sen. Jamie Pedersen, D-Seattle. Pedersen was the only person to speak in support of his bill.

A proposed substitute bill discussed at the hearing would exempt the legislature from disclosing a variety of documents, including records dealing with harassment, sexual assault or misconduct allegations, whistleblower protections, and constituent communications.

Pederson noted that Thurston County Superior Court ruled that the legislature is only obligated to disclose things that are currently considered public records and final sexual assault investigation reports are not included.

“A year ago, we went through a very painful experience with 6617 that flew through,” Pederson said. “The things that I heard from my constituents told me that we needed to go in a very different direction.”

In 2018, a bill was passed in two days without public testimony after a Thurston County Superior Court judge ruled in January 2018 that the legislature was subject to the Public Records Act and had not been in compliance for years.

The lawmakers and the media outlets that sued them both appealed the ruling to the state Supreme Court.

Rowland Thompson of Allied Daily Newspapers and also representing the Washington State Newspaper Publishers Association testified in opposition to Pedersen’s bill. The WNPA, along with the Associated Press and other news outlets, are plaintiffs in the lawsuit against the lawmakers.

“We would rather lose the case than have this bill,” Thompson said. “If we accept this bill it’s an acquiescence on our part that your positions in the lawsuit are correct because most of them are carried forward in this bill.”

Thompson spoke at length on objections to the proposed bill, saying this changes how the Public Records Act would apply to the legislative body as a whole. The act applies to the individual elected officials on governing bodies throughout the state, such as city councils and county commissions.

Last year a Thurston County Superior Court judge ruled that the law also applies to state legislators.

David Zeeck, who recently retired after decades as publisher of the Tacoma News Tribune, stated that with the proposed law, “it appears that the the legislature is trying to legislate itself out of a problem in the courts.”

Frank Blethen, publisher of the Seattle Times, also a plaintiff in the lawsuit against the legislature, testified in opposition to the bill. Asking the media to compromise here is asking them to bet against themselves in the court case, Blethen said.

“This not a battle you’re going to win in the court of public opinion,” Blethen added.

Cecilia Rexus, a member of the Tri City Herald editorial board, called in to give testimony in opposition of the bill.

“I find it troubling that we are having this conversation at all,” Rexus said. “This bill is going down the same road as last year. It was going the wrong direction then, and it’s going the wrong direction now.”

Laurie Williams, editor of the Tri City Herald, added: “This change that you’re proposing sends the wrong message, I think, in an era that is rife with conspiracy theories, paranoia, distrust and so-called fake news. This is not the time to give the public the sense that you have something to hide.”

Chairman Sam Hunt, D- Olympia, concluded the hearing saying: “We are not trying to hide things. We are trying to seek a better solution to clarify things without having to go to court.”

Read the full bill and follow it’s progress here: https://app.leg.wa.gov/billsummary?BillNumber=5784&Year=2019&Initiative=false

Watch hearing here: https://www.tvw.org/watch/?eventID=2019021202

More in News

Petty Officer 1st Class Jessie Ewing of VP-40 is greeted by his daughter Gala Ewing Thursday. He returned to Whidbey Island with the last active duty P-3C Orion.
Last active duty P-3C Orion flies into history

An era of Naval aircraft history came to an end this month… Continue reading

Commissioner will delegate vote for state senate appointment

Island County Commissioner Helen Price Johnson won’t vote on a state senate… Continue reading

Man files another public records lawsuit against Langley

A South Whidbey man has filed another lawsuit against the city of… Continue reading

Island County’s longtime hearing examiner is likely to be replaced

For the first time in more than 30 years, there will be… Continue reading

Navy SAR conducts medical evacuation on Olympic Peninsula

On Oct. 3, a search and rescue team from Naval Air Station… Continue reading

Photo provided by Island County Sheriff’s Office 
                                A Langley man in a single-seat kit aircraft crashed Friday afternoon after his plane lost power while in the process of landing at Whidbey Airpark on South Whidbey.
Langley man injured in fiery plane crash

A 65-year-old Langley man was airlifted to Harborview Medical Center in Seattle… Continue reading

I-976 could detour Island Transit buses

If passed, Initiative 976 has the potential to significantly diminish bus and… Continue reading

Newspaper writers win top awards

Two Whidbey News Group staff members received top writing awards at a… Continue reading

Whidbey hikers beware, hunting season is here

Hikers, bikers, runners, horseback riders and general wanderers of Whidbey trails should… Continue reading

Most Read