Spate of clearcuts on the horizon: Permits OK’d for 90 acres, pending for another 44

An influx of clearcuts is coming to Whidbey Island, according to recent Department of Natural Resources decisions analyzed by a local environmental-protection group.

An influx of clearcuts is coming to Whidbey Island, according to recent Department of Natural Resources decisions analyzed by a local environmental-protection group.

In April alone, that state agency, often known as DNR, approved 90.75 acres for clearcutting, and left pending applications to clearcut another 44 acres, said Marianne Edain, a coordinator with Whidbey Environment Action Network, or WEAN.

Another 38.5 acres were approved for thinning.

“We are anti-clearcutting, not anti-logging,” Edain said, addressing a meeting of the county’s planning commission on May 9.

“Clearcutting is a disastrous form of logging, and there are many examples of very successful selective logging. If you take two percent of a forest per year, you can do that forever.”

The clearcuts — set out in Forest Practice “notices of decision” approving harvests of 70 percent or more of the trees on a property — are slated to occur at the southwest corner of the intersection of Lone Lake and Goss Lake Roads, in Langley; at the intersection of Libbey and West Beach Roads, between Coupeville and Oak Harbor; off Sleeper Road southwest of Dugualla State Park, near Oak Harbor; off Lone Lake Road near Saratoga Road, in Langley; Becker Road, near the Bayview Road dog park, in Bayview; and just south of Chase Lake, north of Freeland.

No start dates are provided. Some of the sites to be logged involve slopes with grades of up to 50 percent, according to the notices.

Some clearcuts are conversions, meaning the land will be built on. Most by law must be reforested — though “what that actually means in practice varies widely,” Edain said. In any case, she said, “A replanted clearcut is not a forest — it is a rather sad tree farm.”

WEAN hasn’t consistently tracked Forest Practice notices of decision, said Edain, but “my sense is that clearcutting has been increasing over the past year.”

Tracking clearcuts and their effects is hard, she said, in part because of internal inconsistencies within applications. For example, one recent application cited plans to cut 80 percent of 26 acres at Lone Lake and Goss Lake roads, but claimed to be exempt from the requirement to reforest the area, checking the box claiming, “I am leaving at least 100 vigorous, undamaged and well-distributed saplings or merchantable trees per acre.”

If those 100 trees represent the 20 percent uncut on each acre, there must be another 400 trees making up the 80 percent to be cut, Edain observed.

“So 500 vigorous, merchantable trees per acre? That’s a pretty high number — unrealistically high.”

Not necessarily, responded Steve Ranten, the forest-practice coordinator for DNR’s Northwest region. “It’s really hard to tell whether that’s realistic without seeing the site, but in a multi-age stand, it is possible,” he said.

DNR imposes stringent controls on clearcuts, Ranten said. “There are many restrictions in black and white, and our foresters do a tremendous amount of field review.”

Regulations preclude clearcuts of greater than 40 acres on saltwater islands like Whidbey, for example.

Some defend clearcuts. The Washington Forest Protection Association, an Olympia-based group of private forest-land owners including logging giants Campbell Global, Rayonier and Weyerhaeuser, said both economic and ecological rationales support clearcuts.

Douglas fir depend on full-sun conditions to thrive — conditions that occur after a fire or a massive windstorm. Clearcutting simulates those conditions to create an open area, the group said on its website. Large-scale harvests disturb the forest soil and water less than frequent, smaller incursions, it said.

A lot of Island County residents would like to see the county gain full control over logging, excluding the state altogether, said Bill Poss, development coordinator in the county’s public-works department. At the moment, the county regulates logging only when landowners cut timber to clear a site for building, not when they harvest. “But the county’s perspective is that we’re obligated to administer the regulations as they are, not as they could be,” Poss said.

 

More in News

Washington State House Republican Communications photo — Rep. Norma Smith, R-Clinton, introduced a bill to enforce net neutrality in Washington state.
Rep. Smith, R-Clinton, introduces net neutrality bill

The day before the Federal Communications Commission ended net neutrality, a Republican… Continue reading

Parking proposal makes Langley business owners uneasy

Two design proposals concerning changes to parking on First Street in Langley… Continue reading

Safe Ride Home revs up for second run

A sign with the words “please don’t drink and drive” was erected… Continue reading

Counties pressure state to fund mandates

Island County is joining an effort to get the state’s attention regarding… Continue reading

A house for sale in Coupeville. Island County recently completed a housing needs analysis and found most of the available housing stock are single-family homes, which leaves a deficit for lower income individuals. Photo by Laura Guido/Whidbey News-Times
Report outlines countywide housing needs

A recent housing needs analysis found a significant deficit in available, affordable… Continue reading

New South Whidbey School Board director sworn in

Freeland resident Andrea Downs was sworn into position 2 on the South… Continue reading

Gym floor project at South Whidbey Elementary School South Campus gets new cost

A previous bid for new gym flooring at South Whidbey Elementary School… Continue reading

Police investigating report that Oak Harbor student was accosted

Oak Harbor police are investigating a report that a student was accosted… Continue reading

New tenants added to South Whidbey Community Center

The South Whidbey School Board approved five new leases for tenants at… Continue reading

Most Read