Whidbey judge silences jet-noise lawsuit against Whidbey real estate companies

A judge threw out a lawsuit against two Whidbey real-estate companies over disclosures related to aircraft noise Friday afternoon. “We were victorious,” said Eric Mitten, broker and owner with Windermere Real Estate. “The judge ruled that the disclosure was adequate to put buyers on notice that there was aircraft noise.”

A judge threw out a lawsuit against two Whidbey real-estate companies over disclosures related to aircraft noise Friday afternoon.

“We were victorious,” said Eric Mitten, broker and owner with Windermere Real Estate. “The judge ruled that the disclosure was adequate to put buyers on notice that there was aircraft noise.”

Attorneys representing two Coupeville residents, Jonathan Deegan and Alice O’Grady, filed the class action complaint for damages and injunctive relief against Windermere Real Estate and Acorn Properties on Nov. 18, 2014.

The lawsuit argued that the residents were given only one of two noise disclosures related to Navy aircraft noise that are required under Island County code.

Attorneys representing the real estate company filed a motion to dismiss in May. The motion argued, in part, that the defendants committed no unfair or deceptive acts under the state Consumer Protection Act because the disclosure that was provided was enough to alert the homeowners to the noise impacts and that reasonable inspection would have revealed the facts available in the other disclosure statement.

In the end, the judge agreed with the real-estate companies and dismissed the lawsuit. The hearing was heard in Skagit County Superior Court after Island County judges recused themselves.

Under Island County code, the commissioners require real estate agents to present two different disclosure forms to prospective buyers of homes within the “impacted areas” in the vicinity of Whidbey Island Naval Air Station’s Ault Field in Oak Harbor and the Outlying Field near Coupeville.

The lawsuit claimed violation of the state Consumer Protection Act. It asked for class-action status, as well as damages and a requirement that the real estate company provide the correct disclosure.

Real estate companies had been providing buyers with a one-paragraph disclosure, which comes from a 1993 ordinance regarding the sound-proofing of building in noise zones. But a different ordinance, adopted in 1992, includes much more detail for a separate disclosure, including a pronouncement that “noise generated by a single flyover of a military jet may exceed 100 DBA,” the lawsuit states.

The plaintiffs claimed that in recent years aircraft noise had increased with the introduction of the EA-18G Growler and additional practice flights at OLF Coupeville. The lawsuit stated that community members complained to the county commissioners that they were never told about the “extremely loud noise and vibrations.”

“After investigation, Island County’s government discovered that the complaints had merit — real estate sellers and brokers were not giving ICC 9.44.050’s mandatory disclosure,” the lawsuit states.

In December of 2013, the Island County planning director wrote a memorandum to the board of commissioners noting that sellers were not providing buyers with both disclosure statements. In response, the Whidbey Island Association of Realtors took “prompt action to correct its standard disclosure,” according to the motion to dismiss.

By the end of January of 2014, real estate agents started using an updated disclosure form that included language from both ordinances, the defendants’ motion states.

 

More in News

Expert says chief followed right protocol

David Marks’ arrest of suspect ‘exactly what we teach’

Photos by Whidbey Camano Land Trust
                                Taylor Schmuki, left, and Kyle Ostermick-Durkee, both part of the Whidbey Camano Land Trust’s stewardship team, study the plant life this spring in a newly protected forest on South Whidbey.
Conservation Buyer Saves a Whidbey Island Forest

By RON NEWBERRY Special to the Record Pat Powell has worked with… Continue reading

Sailor shoots man, himself

A Navy man shot another man and then himself in Oak Harbor… Continue reading

Trooper, ranger try to prevent man from jumping off bridge

A trooper with the Washington State Patrol and a ranger with State… Continue reading

Valetta Faye will perform at Ott & Murphy Wines in Langley.
Singing sensation comes to South Whidbey

Singing is her passion, music is her soul. That’s singer Valetta Faye’s… Continue reading

Shhh…it’s a surprise party for old-timer Bill Lanning

Friends, customers invited to celebrate former owner of Bill’s Feed Tack

Retail sales grew in Island County, Langley

New numbers released by the state Department of Revenue show that Island… Continue reading

Hometown Heroes gets second book

Hometown Hero Book 2 is in the works. All money will go… Continue reading

Bayview Nights Car Show set

Safe Ride Home is holding the 2018 Cool Bayview Nights Car Show… Continue reading

Most Read