Editorial: Navy’s fight for freedom should include freedom of information

Regardless of how you feel about the Citizens of Ebey’s Reserve and its stance on jet noise, the group’s victory in a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit against the Navy should be considered a victory for all citizens.

The federal lawsuit was dismissed this week after the Navy finally produced the required records and responses to several requests COER made for documents.

The Navy also paid $17,500 in attorney’s fees.

The Freedom of Information Act, commonly known as FOIA, was signed into law of July 4, 1966. It’s a uniquely American law that provides citizens with the right to know the people’s business.

After all, a democracy cannot function with the consent of the governed if the governed doesn’t know what the government is doing.

COER wanted information about the Navy’s testing of groundwater for contaminants, the Growler engines and noise testing.

They weren’t outlandish requests, but even if they were, the Navy and the Department of Defense is required to respond in a manner prescribed by law.

One would think the Navy has people trained to do this.

It’s ironic, perhaps, that the Navy that boasts “the sound of freedom” and fights for freedom should violate a law that guarantees an important freedom.

It’s unfortunate that the Navy forced the group to hire an attorney and go through a lengthy administrative and legal struggle to obtain the response required by law. A citizen without such resources likely wouldn’t have been able to follow through on such actions, which sets up a system in which those with money have more access to the government.

The Founding Fathers, subsequent presidents, philosophers and giants of the Supreme Court have all stressed the importance of having informed citizens.

Quotes are easy to find on the subject from Thomas Jefferson, John Adams, James Madison and others.

For example, Patrick Henry said this: “The liberties of people never were, nor ever will be, secure when the transactions of their rulers may be concealed from them.”

More in Opinion

Sound Off: The sooner we’re vaccinated, the sooner we’ll be back to normal

We all wish COVID-19 was over, don’t you? Eighteen months into this… Continue reading

Dave Paul
Sound Off: Local law enforcement needs continued investments

In my three years in office, I’ve spent a lot of time… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Servers need higher wages, even if it means $10 shakes

Workers simply need a livable wage, not just a living wage.

In Our Opinion: Unvaccinated need to take responsibility for their choices

The pandemic in America would be over if everyone had gotten vaccinated.… Continue reading

Rockin’ a Hard Place: An irresistible urge to emerge takes hold, on and off the Rock

One of the benefits of this urge for me was recalling what I miss about our Rock while far from it.

In Our Opinion: With tourism at all-time high, change in investment needed

More money could be spent on long-term, concrete investments related to tourism.

In Our Opinion: Meetings should be recorded, posted online even after COVID

One of the few silver linings of the pandemic has been the… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Barriers to prevent bridge suicides worth considering

Two suicides at Deception Pass Bridge in July have reignited a community… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Island County’s pandemic bonuses are a smart idea, if legal

The latest federal stimulus plan, the American Rescue Plan Act of 2021,… Continue reading

In Our Opinion: Welcome back, Whidbey Island Fair, how we missed ya

After a year marked by fear, divisiveness and distancing, attending the Whidbey… Continue reading

My garden.
On the Rock, we walk, wander and garden while the sun shines

During sunshine, we are outdoors walking our trails, wandering our beaches and tending our gardens.

In Our Opinion: Ships should follow same environmental rules as everyone else

Over the last year, giant hulking figures emitting low, intrusive rumbles have… Continue reading