Letter: Letter author shows a lack of empathy, understanding

Editor,

I had to respond to the letter, “Immigrants illegally in U.S. should pay a price” from the Sept. 4 South Whidbey Record.

This epic starts with “My wife is foreign born…” and devolves into a family history of his and the many “foreign born” co-workers and friends who “came from all areas of the globe except South America.”

I guess the point of the letter is to show how “inclusive” the writer is. This writer is, of course, “native born American.”

I have to assume that all of these foreign-born people in his family tree had something to do with his being here and, of course, “native born American.” Lucky him.

My biggest issue with this missive from Mr. Brown, aside from the underlying disdain he seems to have for other humans who are not “native born” like him, is the falsity, “I do not like a lifetime of paying into Social Security, Medicare and other programs and not being able to collect the full benefits because assets in those programs are being withdrawn to support illegal immigrants and other Pork Barrel projects.”

Mr. Brown, if you are in America without papers, you cannot get Social Security or Medicare. This is a myth. This is the very “propaganda” you spoke of in your letter. I assume you got this specious information from watching right-wing political propaganda on television.

If you have undertaken the perilous journey to save your family by escaping political or drug cartel violence in South or Central America, I consider you a hero.

Read and learn about these places. I would recommend you read “Illegal People” by David Bacon. I think you’ll find that much of this violence stems from American political/economic policies.

To equate this life or death journey to a speeding ticket is beyond my grasp as a human being.

Dan Freeman

Clinton

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Don’t allow developers to be only voice in growth

Editor, I read that one of the oldest native madrona trees on… Continue reading

Letter: ‘A few hoodlums’ at the Capitol Jan. 6. Really?

Editor, In contrast to Fred Wilferth, on Jan. 20 I took my… Continue reading

Letter: I Support the Girls sets ambitious goal for 2021

Ediwtor, We the volunteers of I Support the Girls Whidbey Island welcome… Continue reading

Letter: Sad to read about removal of Oak Harbor madrona

Editor, I was disheartened to learn of the planned removal of the… Continue reading

Letter: Edit letters for brevity, decency and frequency

Editor, As a subscriber, I am writing to ask you to please… Continue reading

Letter: Biden mistaken if he thinks he has a handle on dissent

Editor, Today I will take down my American flag, fold it and… Continue reading

Letter: ‘I wear my mask to protect you, Fred’

Editor, In response to Fred Wilferth‘s Jan. 15 letter to the editor… Continue reading

Letter: Find a safe alternative to returning to classes

Editor, If we as parents didn’t know what social-emotional learning was before… Continue reading

Letter: If you see Gretchen, be sure to thank her

Editor, Change can be difficult. Change and transitions happen in our lives.… Continue reading

Most Read