Letter: Navy philosophy dismisses locals’ Growler concerns

Editor,

The Langley resident who dismissed the concerns of people living near the touch-and-go landing strip in Coupeville where the Growlers practice is lacking both facts and historical perspective.

She claims that the landing strip predates many of the locals, and that folks who live there now have no right to complain.

The landing strip was built in the early 1940s, whereas some of today’s farmers on Ebey’s Prairie are descended from those who homesteaded generations ago.

William Henry Sherman arrived in 1896; several of his descendants still live in the area and farm their family’s land. And, if “who got here first” is to be the determinant of whether Ebey’s Reserve should be subjected to constant and deafening noise, shouldn’t the descendants of the Lower Skagit people, who were the prairie’s first farmers, have the final say?

I agree with her that our military should have a safe place to practice maneuvers. Coupeville’s outlying field is not a safe place for Growler field carrier landing practice.

The 5,400-foot runway, built to accommodate aircraft built in the 1940s, is nearly 3,500 feet too short for Growler jet “touch-and-go” operations, which require 8,800 feet. The runway cannot be extended.

For 32 years, the runway has failed to meet Navy runway safety standards. Furthermore, to provide acceptable civilian safeguards and livability, the Navy prefers at least 2,000 of unsettled acres to conduct a training program of this kind.

Yet the Navy conducts training missions over 664 acres of populated land on Whidbey Island.

Thus, the Navy is in violation of its own safety standards, thereby putting civilians, pilots and aircraft, each one costing upwards of $85 million, at risk.

“Please excuse our noise, it’s the sound of freedom” is a Navy slogan that does little to address the legitimate, pressing concerns of islanders about the proposed increase of Growlers over Central Whidbey.

Like most slogans, it’s a simplification that disguises a multitude of wrongs — which is, I suspect, its very purpose.

Dianna MacLeod

Langley

More in Letters to the Editor

Letters: Kudos to Johnson for ensuring CARES funds fairly disbursed

Editor, I would like to thank Island County Commissioner Jill Johnson for… Continue reading

Letter: Voting for Damian Greene would be a smart move

Editor, I was very encouraged to see Damian Greene enter the race… Continue reading

Letter: Fixating on Trump’s defeat is detrimental to the country

Editor, In response to Cheri Filion’s letter to the editor in the… Continue reading

Letter: Congrats to 2020 recipients of Oak Harbor Music Festival scholarships

Editor, I would like to congratulate the recipients of the Oak Harbor… Continue reading

Letter: Grateful for access to water that boat launch, beach provide

Editor, In response to Mike Christen and Jami Robinson Christen’s letter to… Continue reading

Letter: Sheriff clearly cares about his deputies, public at large

Editor, Thank God for Sheriff Felici. He obviously cares about his deputies… Continue reading

Letter: ‘It is President Trump who is using Hitler’s playbook’

Editor, Recent letters to the editor have made it apparent that the… Continue reading

Letter: Wearing a mask is akin to wearing clothes in public

Editor, Just out of curiosity, why is being asked to wear a… Continue reading

Letter: Experience with fake $20 was defnitely eye-opening

Editor, Having seen much discussion about passing fake $20 being a crime,… Continue reading

Most Read