Controversial BLM post deleted but debate continues

United Student Leaders removed a controversial online post about school board member Damian Greene.

United Student Leaders, a student activist group from South Whidbey, removed a controversial Facebook post about school board member Damian Greene from their page.

The group, known as USL, indicated that the decision to remove the comment was not related to Greene’s disclosure that he was consulting an attorney about it.

The South Whidbey Record story on the controversy was subsequently covered by Newsweek, an Egyptian news blog and Opera News, the largest news app in the world.

USL’s original post followed a protest against the South Whidbey School District’s Black Lives Matter banner and other topics, organized by Greene’s wife Maureen. Days after the protest, the banner was stolen from school grounds.

The USL post encouraged community members to attend the June 23 board meeting and ask questions such as “What was Maureen and/or Damian’s role in the stealing and vandalizing of the banners?”

In that school board meeting, Greene denounced the post as “libel, slander, with the intent to defame our characters,” and revealed he was speaking with an attorney about it.

Later, in a statement to the The Record, Greene said, “Certainly, nobody desires to enter into litigation. Hopefully it is not needed to fully learn the lesson here. This issue could have been resolved and still can, by USL simply removing the post.”

In a separate email to the The Record, and again in a July 28 school board meeting, Greene said he did not mean either statement as a threat of litigation against the students.

“At no time did I say I was going to file a lawsuit against the United Student Leaders,” he wrote in the email to The Record.

“There are many reasons to visit with an attorney, especially in this disturbing situation with a non-recognized school district community group consisting of ‘some’ South Whidbey students,” the email went on.

In a new Facebook post, USL said their decision to remove the post was motivated by a desire to return to their original purpose of advocating for climate justice and providing a safe space for student activists.

“We stand by the questions we raised, however, we regret that the Greenes interpreted our post as an accusation. Because of the misinterpretation we realize that our intent could have been more clear,” the post said. “We also want to clarify that neither Damian nor Maureen have contacted USL to discuss concerns and request for the removal of the post.”

The Black Lives Matter banner continued to be a subject of passionate debate at the July 28 board meeting, when public commenters spent nearly an hour and a half expressing their support for, or displeasure with, the banner and other social justice education measures that were the subjects of the June 11 protest.

Maureen Greene and others repeated their long-held assertions that the banner violates the standard of political neutrality to which public schools must adhere because of the Black Lives Matter political action committee created in October 2020.

“If you continue to display the banner, then members of the public are afforded equal opportunity for expression of opposing views,” Maureen Greene said.

There isn’t a single group that represents Black Lives Matter, but it’s a decentralized grassroots movement represented by many different organizations and individuals that advocate against police violence toward Black people.

Board members also weighed in during the part of the meeting dedicated to board comments and reports. Board chair Brook Willeford maintained that the banner’s purpose is not to endorse any political ideology, but to affirm to students of color that they are safe and valued at South Whidbey High School.

“What is the opposing view to Black Lives Matter? Is it ‘all lives matter’? No,” he said. “The only opposing view to the statement ‘Black lives matter’ is that Black lives don’t matter, and that is not a statement I will ever vote for or speak out in favor of on school property.”

Board member Marnie Jackson wondered whether a banner with a similar phrase might retain the inclusive sentiment while assuaging the concerns of community members who view the original terminology as political.

“I think it would be a slap in the face and a threat to the safety of our students to take down the banner that says ‘Black Lives Matter,’ unless they were to replace it with a like statement, like perhaps a statement that says, ‘All Black lives truly matter,’” she said.

More in News

Phony money left in church collection box | Island Scanner

Wednesday, Sept. 29 At 3:10 p.m., caller started laughing manically and said… Continue reading

Photo provided
This plaque was removed from Deception Pass bridge during painting. Anyone with information about how to reach the family of Todd A. Kelly should reach out to Jason Armstrong.
Park seeks to return plaques

The plaques were apparently placed as memorials for Brian R. Rudolph and Todd A. Kelly.

Washington State Patrol Chief John Batiste, center, greets a new trooper during a graduation ceremony, as Gov. Jay Inslee looks on in the Rotunda at the Capitol Thursday, Dec. 13, 2018, in Olympia, Wash. The class of 31 troopers completed more than 1,000 hours of training and will now work for the WSP across the state. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Rather than get vaccine, nearly 2,000 state workers lose jobs

Ten troopers north of Seattle, 54 Monroe prison workers and hundreds more across the state refused the governor’s mandate.

Man accused of assaulting woman, stealing phone, calling to threaten her

A Langley man is being held in jail on a $25,000 bail bond and facing a long list of charges.

Tiny House group bemoans big connection fees

Members of an affordable housing project tried to secure a discount for fees it already paid.

Langley city council ponders salary increases

Langley City Council members were divided on the topic of salary increases for the mayor and staff.

Photo by Dean Petrich
Ferry twice stalled by wayward watercraft

The ferry was already behind schedule when a small boat capsized near the Clinton terminal’s dock.

Council looks to state rep for help with ferry woes

State Rep. Dave Paul was invited to a Langley city council meeting to speak about recent ferry cuts.

Service temporarily restored to Clinton-Mukilteo ferry route

Despite major slashes, the first weekend of an abridged ferry schedule saw some pleasant surprises.

Most Read