Federalist Papers are not the end-all of political debate


In response to Mr. Harry S. Hansen’s letter from Dec. 20, “The U.S. is a constitutional republic”: You’re right that we live in a republic, not a pure democracy (although I doubt that’s what Ms. Ann Adams believes either when she uses the term democracy).

The issue regarding the electoral college remains: we live in a republic in which officials are elected to represent the people, yet the president is neither elected by the people nor representative of the people. As long as the electors themselves are not elected by the people and are free to vote for whomever they choose, the president does not represent the people. Who are these electors? What are their names? What religion are they? What do they think about climate change, globalization, monetary policy, abortion, or gay rights?

True, the electoral college works just fine as designed, and it is what the framers intended, but it doesn’t mean it’s what’s best for us today. The Federalist Papers, while respectable, are not the end-all of political debate, so it’s not helpful to tell people to just refer to Federalist 10 and 14 and be quiet.


Oak Harbor

More in Letters to the Editor

Letter:Shout out to local restaurants for being very child-friendly

Editor, I wanted to take a moment to thank all the restaurants… Continue reading

Letter:A story of ‘adventure’ with WhidbeyHeath referral

Editor, This may amuse other Whidbey residents who’ve dealt with WhidbeyHealth. A… Continue reading

Letter: Drunk driving laws in state need to be reviewed, improved

Editor, I don’t write letters normally, and here I am with the… Continue reading

Letter: Contrast between Trump, Obama could not be any greater

Editor, During the first weekend of September we witnessed a memorial service… Continue reading

Letter: Reasons to elect Janet St. Clair as commissioner

Editor, I’m voting for Janet St. Clair for Island County commissioner 3.… Continue reading

Letter: The loud ‘sound of freedom’ drowns out everything else

Editor, It’s 6 p.m. A gorgeous, warm, late summer evening. But we… Continue reading

Letter: Ultimate Frisbee a safer sport than football — switch it out

Editor, I read with pleasure the article last week about local Whidbey… Continue reading

Letter: Buyers beware of the listed property descriptions online

Editor, Talk about ‘caveat emptor.’ I recently submitted a complaint to the… Continue reading

Letter: Striving to provide the best in recreation programs, parks

Editor, We write this letter to thank the South Whidbey community for… Continue reading

Letter: Restoration project needs experts who’ve walked beach

Editor, Small fish were jumping by the dozens in the Hidden Beach… Continue reading

Letter: Administration spouts lies, nonsense; vote in November

Editor, “Truth isn’t truth.” Come on, Giuliani, what kind of baloney is… Continue reading

Letter: Teachers deserve excellent, salaries, sustainable ones

Editor, The South Whidbey School District is currently bargaining with its teachers.… Continue reading