Letter: Rebman’s letter is very incorrect and misleading


I am writing in response to the Oct. 23 letter from Lee Rebman that accuses county commissioner candidate Janet St. Clair of being a “carpetbagger” who is beholden to special interest. Rebman’s letter is incorrect and misleading.

Following Rebman’s lead, I went to the State Public Disclosure Commission’s website and found the campaign disclosures for both candidates.

Ms. St. Clair did have less than 10 out-of-state donors, accounting for about 1 percent of her donors. She also had a handful of out-of-county donors from Seattle and other cities, but so did Rick Hannold, with donations from Redmond, Kirkland, Bellingham and other cities.

So, according to Rebman’s definition, shouldn’t we also consider Hannold a “carpetbagger” who is beholden to outside interest? The bottom line is, the vast majority of donations for both candidates are from within the county; there is no smoking gun that would show either candidate being “bought” by outside interests. One thing that is true in Rebman’s letter is that Janet St. Clair has more donors and more campaign support within our county. But what is so wrong with strong local support for a candidate?

David Freed


More in Letters to the Editor

Letter: Navy, country need place for Growlers to practice

Editor, As a retired master chief who served at Whidbey Island, both… Continue reading

Letter: Our island community making a big difference

Editor, Thanks to Laura Guido for her article, “Making Art to Make… Continue reading

Letter: Insurance cuts a slap in the face

Editor, WhidbeyHealth recently announced budget cuts, as noted in the South Whidbey… Continue reading

Letter: Arrest by deputies’ helped avert potential tragedy

Editor, On Nov. 21, we on Whidbey Island were very likely in… Continue reading

Letter: Not anti-defense; against being ‘collateral damage’

Editor, I read the South Whidbey Record Dec. 5 article, “Navy ends… Continue reading

Letter: Frustrated by a lack of enforcement by county

Editor, It is in the spirit of continuous improvement that I write… Continue reading

Letter: Goal of matching large donation met at event

Editor, I would like to extend a personal thank you to all… Continue reading

Letter: Road etiquette and safety is important and serious

Editor, I complain about this all the time and I do my… Continue reading

Letter: WIN thankful for support community has shown

Editor, Whidbey Island Nourishes, or WIN, is celebrating the generosity of local… Continue reading

Most Read